by dmac » Thu Feb 01, 2018 4:39 am
When considering the "Bo Wanted Sue" aspect of the alibis, it also makes far more sense with Marty shagging Sue regularly.
So many aspects of the Loonibi were devised to hide or confuse truths: Marty was fucking Sue, Loon found out, so Sue had to die to protect Loon's batting average of being the one who fucked her men over before they strayed from her spread-leg black hole sun.
Marty was fucking Sue, so how would MMB lie to hide that?
a> Sue was looked at as a strong woman in her community who left her abusive husband. Loon respected that, and was being advised by Sue directly to leave abusive Marty.
b> Sue and Loon were friends, not enemies. They often shared tea.
c> Loon didn't know Sue's kids well, other than Tina, who came over often. Loon even helped her with the class assignment that involved the missing shoebox: a diarama.
d> Marty had no interest in Sue. In fact, he wanted to set Bo (and Dee and Wade and Tony and...) up with Sue... because Marty had NO SEXUAL OR EMOTIONAL INTEREST IN SUE.
e> all of the above- and far more.
When Loon and Nina revised the Lunabi into Tunabi, what still fits?
a> Marty called Sue a whore and Tina a whore.
b> If it bleeds it breeds.
c> Marty was incredibly pissed Sue didn't be Bo's date, and it got worse as the night progressed.
d> No, it was Bo who was incredibly pissed Sue wasn't Bo's date, and it got worse as the night progressed.
e> all of the above, and far more.
Oddly, what lines up pretty well is Nina's account of Marty's Fucky Mountain Breakdown in jail, and his tirade against Wade: "We got her, we'll get you too!"
In the first place, it's so damned funny Nina remembers that secondhand info as accurately as the police report, yet says she last waved goodbye to her best friend at 6 pm (she remembers because she looked at the clock) on May 12 1981- when month-dead Sue and her murdered family left the birthday party for her son, Walter. Yet, she never spoke to Loon by phone on Sat, April 11? Never notified Sue when Johnny and Dana should be home, despite Rick remembering the phone call so well***? Did Nina tell Sue that they'd be home late, don't wait up, leave the door open? Sure, Sue left the door open all the time, as did most Keddie-ites, but Nina is so unfamiliar with her 'best friend', Sue, perhaps the set-up needed confirmation she'd leave the doors unlocked.
In the second, Marty is telling Wade and EVERYONE ELSE IN THE SHERIFF'S OFFICE the murder of Sue was at his hands, and IT WAS ABOUT DRUGS. Not only that, Marty was fucking Sue and Loon was fucking Wade. Between the time of the murders and the jail exchange... or, perhaps, prior to the murders... Marty twigged his young bestie was fucking his wife.
As were others, according to his phone rant from Klammath to a friend, who I believe is Mr A. Marty threatened to come back to Keddie and finish what he started, by killing all of Loon's lovers.
Marty had killed Sue and family as a vow to restore his marriage to Loon. Loon dumped him within hours of his carrying out Loon's decree that Sue must pay. Marty confessed to her that he'd just paid for Loon's love with four lives (he had FIVE KIDS, not four, so the implication is explicit), and was so pissed that she dumped him that the very day he wrote and mailed that letterfrom the Arcade Hotel, he called Mr A that night and threatened to come back and kill Loon's fuckers. Plural. FuckerS.
For years I've said the whole thing was about Sue, the sole target was Sue. Marty clearly had a thing for Sue. Then I heard from one of Josh's producers- who dumped his lame, felonious ass- that she'd been told by multiple sources it was an open secret Marty had a boner to pick with Sue. Then it recently comes from a vetted source that Sue and Marty were a couple- despite the source's knowledge Marty was married to Loon- and that Marty was so protective and jealous of his conquest (Sue) that it creeped out many people. And that is a slap in the face to people who've followed this case for years? Really? Fucking, REALLY? Try working the case, rather than being the deuce-douchebag who plays lamefuck Monday Morning Backseat Driver QB to a tosser armchair detective like me.
Despite all of this shit being laid out on this forum for donkeys ears, and the fact the Marty/Sue affair makes the murders- and so many of the inbred lies- so fucking simple (well, probably BECAUSE it makes everything simple, a bit of a let-down for Unsolved Enthusiasts), many decry the affair as a bullshit lie.
Who the fuck is the bullshitter and liar, if one is too simple to see the simplest answer IS the truth? Occams Razor, assholes.
When one strips away the bullshit about Bo being after Sue, about the music change, about Loon knocking on Sue's door, about Loon being home and asleep/awake when Bo and Marty returned to 26 @ 2am, what's left is the truth, and the subtext in the L/Tunabis support that Marty was fucking Sue, Loon found out, Loon ordered Sue's put-down, Marty Bo AND LOON (AND JUSTIN) did the killings, and then lied in their joint alibi to make it seem Marty had no interest in Sue, that Marty even proffered Sue to Bo, and that Dana- no Tina's dad- did the killings because the target was TINA, not Sue.
That's not new math, not quick math. It's just plain old motherfucking math.
PS: Dogfur, it's pretty solid that Sly fucked anything that moved. He'd fuck a box of donut holes if he thought they were holes. It's also pretty firm that Sly was fucking Jan Albin. Try this: records indicate it was Jan Albin who ran Keddie. It was Jan who provided PCSO with info on residents, info about kicking out 13 & 15 for drugs, and holding back about Sheriff Sly Thomas- her lover- being the penultimate occupant in 28.
*** Rick remembered the "Who's this?!" phone call and the call where Sue was informed by Nina that Johnny and Dana were together and arrive home later. Imagine Sue that night, where she would be: Couch Potato A#1 Sharp, present and accounted for, in her only known spot: the dent on the right corner of the couch. FURTHEST FROM THE PHONE. Besides, Sue was Meeks as a mouse, she'd never answer the phone! Filthy thing! Sheila and Tina weren't home for either call, Greg was five, Justin was just a contentious objector visiting from the north, which left Rick to answer the phone. Both times? No explicit indication he picked up the phone either time? The first was a male caller? Female? But the second call, he knew that was Nina Meeks. He knows Nina told Sue that Dana and Johnny would be home later, that they were safe, yada yada. Either Rick or Sue picked up the phone, but it was confirmed by Rick that Nina called, and re-affirmed by Sheila that, when she returned from 27 to 28 to get nightclothes, Sue told her J&D were together and would be coming home later.
SUE LEFT THE DOORS UNLOCKED, AND LEFT THE LIGHT ON IN THE BATHROOM WHEN SHE WENT TO BED. Whether or not it was Nina's part of A DEAL, THE STAGE WAS PERFECTLY SET FOR THE MURDERS.
"Back off, man. I'm a scientist."
reach me at
keddie28 AT gmail DOT com